Well it could be true. I'm a sucker for the Gears of War's concept, imagery and all so I could have a biased opinion here. I think we all agree that technically Halo's concept and execution is flawless, you can really tell they put huge ammounts of effort in every little detail. But as to originality, it is not the most original piece of work on the planet, so I think Luis got a point here.

Anyways the book looks awesome, I'll definetly buy it.