I've finally gotten around to reviewing the Van Gogh 12 half-pan watercolour set that I bought a long time ago.
Van Gogh watercolours are made by Royal Talens from Netherlands. They are also the same company that makes the Rembrandt watercolours. Although it's not mentioned on their website, I read somewhere that the Van Gogh watercolours are student grade paints.
The total range consists of 40 colours. That's enough but not as many compared to other brands. You can also get the colours as tubes.
The set that I bought from Amazon Japan came with a metal box. It came with a small size 4 collapsible brush which is just too small to be used in any satisfactory manner. Also, the brush does not close well because the opening is quite loose.
The price is quite comparable to Winsor & Newton Cotman, the student grade watercolour. Depending on where you're buying it from, it may be more or less expensive than Cotman. A reader told me it's cheaper if you buy it in Netherlands.
Each pan has a product code stamped onto the side. You can use that to compare with the colour chart on Royal Talens website to get information like the pigments used.
These are the colours included in this set
- Chinese White PW4
- Perm Lemon Yellow PY184
- Azo Yellow Medium PY154 + PO62
- Perm Red Light PR254
- Madder Lake Deep PR264
- Cobalt Blue (Ultramarine) PB29 + PW6
- Ultramarine Deep PB29
- Hooker Green Light PG7 + PY154
- Phthalo Green PG7
- Yellow Ochre PY42
- Burnt Sienna PR101 + PBK11
- Payne's Grey Pbk6 + PV19
Colour selection in this set is quite good with the exception of Chinese White. You might want to replace that with a cool blue such as Phthalo Blue or Cerulean.
The two blues included are Cobalt Blue (Ultramarine) and Ultramarine Deep. Interestingly, this version of Cobalt Blue is listed as using PB29, the pigment used to make Ultramarine and also has PW4 which is a white added. Overall, it looks too similar to Ultramarine Deep that is included. Both are warm blues, hence my recommendation of adding a cool blue earlier.
In this sketch, the sky was coloured with Ultramarine Deep and the bike with Cobalt Blue (Ultramarine). The difference is not obvious enough if you use them in heavy concentration.
Most of the colours are relatively transparent except for Yellow Ochre which looks semi-opaque.
There are 7 single pigment colours out of the 12, and one of them is Chinese White.
The colours look vibrant when painted off from their pans.
This is the colour chart created from the set. I skipped Chinese White because I don't really use that.
Overall, the resulting mixtures are quite vibrant and I like what I see. They compare well against artist grade watercolours such as Daniel Smith or Schmincke. I would say Van Gogh colour mixtures appear to be less granular even though there are granulating paints such as Cobalt Blue, Ultramarine Deep, Burnt Sienna and Hooker's Green.
For warm bright orange, you can mix Azo Yellow Medium with Perm Red Light. For bright purples, you can mix either Cobalt Blue or Ultramarine Deep with Madder Lake Deep. For greys, you get nice shades with either Cobalt Blue or Ultramarine Deep with Burnt Sienna, or Phthalo Green with Madder Lake. The two greens are quite convenient too.
To me, the colours feel slightly more vibrant compared to Winsor & Newton Cotman.
While I've said that they are comparable to Daniel Smith and Schmincke, in actual use I find that the colours are definitely not as vibrant. They are slightly more muted. You can say that it's pastel like but it's not too pastel like.
In this sketch I used a lot of Hooker's Green, Phthalo Green and Madder Lake. For the clouds, I used Chinese White. Be careful when using Chinese White because it's more prone to producing bubbles. When you paint over your work, those bubbles will be left on the paper and when it's dry and the bubbles burst, they will leave unwanted marks behind. You may be able to see some big bubble marks on the left page.
Pastel-like or muted, I still like how the colours mix. It's a personal preference, some people prefer really bright colours while others prefer a more subtle colour palette. I use whatever I have with me. For the sketch above, I thought the colours work well together. Most importantly, many of the colours are transparent so it's a great set to be used for pen and ink watercolour artworks or for watercolour sketching.
One thing I noticed about the Van Gogh paints is, I tend to use them up quite quickly. You can get vibrant colours with them, but you also need to use more paint. This is unlike other artist quality paint where you don't have to use as much paint to get the same level of intensity. So the more expensive artist quality paints are still worth the higher price they are sold at.
For the price, I would say it's quite worth the money. I do feel that this is slightly better than Winsor & Newton Cotman. They are of the same price range so if you have a bit more budget, maybe you can consider Van Gogh Watercolor.
Whether you get the white plastic box or the metal box I don't think there's too much difference. Do take a look at the colour selection because sometimes they might differ from what I've listed above.
Search Jackson's Art Supplies (UK) too.